Skip to main content

The Forgotten Mitchell Cemetery of Bentleyville, PA


It’s not every day that you discover an unknown and uncared-for cemetery, but I did and it only took me about 30 years.

In the mid-1990s, I found a copy of Caldwell’s Atlas from 1876 which had a map of Bentleyville that listed a cemetery near the Methodist Church in Bentleyville. Interestingly, there wasn’t a cemetery there.

I asked around, but no one seemed to know anything about a cemetery in the middle of town. Finally, I talked to someone who knew about it, but they dismissed it by saying that it was probably for "paupers.”  I thought it had been paved over or something had been built on it and this was upsetting, to say the least. I didn’t really know how to figure out what had happened to the cemetery and to be honest, after a while, I kind of forgot about it.

Then, last summer my daughter Abby and I were at an antique fair and I found a copy of the Caldwell’s Atlas map of Bentleyville. I bought it and when I took it home, I saw that cemetery again. Last month, I was taking my dog Bernie for a ride and I stopped by the Methodist Church to look around. It seemed to me that the cemetery should be located near the church, the Carlton Restaurant, or the dentist's office, so that’s the area we visited. One of the neighbors pointed me in the direction of a small grassy area behind the dentist's
office at 614 Main Street. She said the previous owner of her property had told her about the cemetery and showed her a rough-hewn stone that was most likely a grave marker.

My research led me to the Washington County Tax Claim office, where I discovered an unclaimed lot behind 614 Main Street that is listed as the Mitchell Cemetery. In addition to being listed on the 1876 map, the cemetery was also listed on the 1888 deed of Isaac Mitchell. The assistant tax assessor said there isn’t a deed to the property and suggested hiring a title searcher to figure it out. He said it is likely the property is owned by an heir of Isaac Mitchell.

I did a quick search of the Mitchell family on Ancestry, but I couldn’t find any local Mitchells who might be the owners. I also discovered that most of the Mitchells who were related to Isaac are buried in Pigeon Creek Cemetery in nearby Somerset Township.

I am the vice president of the Bentleyville Area Historical Society, so I took my findings to the last meeting and discussed it with the members. We are actively looking for the owners of the cemetery and trying to find out who is buried there. Eventually, we would like to mark the cemetery so that it isn’t lost again. Today, I created a listing for the Mitchell Cemetery on Find A Grave, with the hopes that someone with a connection might find it there. If anything, the cemetery now has an identity: Cemetery ID: 2777374.


So, the next time you drive through Bentleyville, please say a little prayer for the poor souls buried in our forgotten little cemetery. If you know anything about the Mitchell Cemetery, please email me at randileeross@gmail.com

Here's the link to the Mitchell Cemetery's new listing on Find A Grave: https://www.findagrave.com/cemetery/2777374/mitchell-cemetery

Written by Randi Ross Marodi


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A 60-year-old letter from my Mom!

As I celebrate my 60th birthday today my thoughts are very much focused on how much I miss my mom and dad. When my mom passed away 10 years ago, I found letters she had written to her mother while she and my dad were living in St. Louis, Mo. in 1964 and 65. I’m so thankful that my grandmother Blanche saved everything, because the following letter details the day I was born: November 29, 1964. My mother was 19 at the time and my dad was 22. The letter was addressed to Mr. and Mrs. George Phillians, Box 883, Clarksville, PA 15322 with a St. Louis, MO Postmark of Dec. 7, 1964. Although my mom’s name was Roberta, her parents and everyone in her family called by her middle name, Lee, which is how she signed this letter. Saturday afternoon (December 5, 1964) Dear Mom & Dad, How are you? Fine I hope! We are all three fine here. Randi is the greatest. (We changed our minds about how to spell her name. We dropped the e & spell it Randi.) She’s so pretty. I guess I’m prejudiced though. H...
Post a Comment
Read more

Vance Ross: A Lifetime of Service

  Three little pins that were found tucked inside a little cardboard box represent my Grandfather Vance Ross’ lifetime of service. The first is his Deacon Emeritus pin presented to him for years of dedication to the Clarksville Christian Church in Clarksville, PA. He did everything at the church from making sure the pipes didn’t freeze, filling the baptismal pool, to serving communion. The middle pin honors 40 years of commitment to the United Mine Workers of America, specifically Local 668 of Fredericktown, PA. He was a big union man who went over each contract with a fine-tooth comb. Just the thought of crossing a picket line was, in his opinion, a cardinal sin. And the third, a tie tack, recognizing over 40 years of service to Republic Steel, where he worked as a coal miner and later as an electrician. He was on-call at all times, often leaving the dinner table to drive to the shaft so he could fix the fan or get the elevator running. He never complained, he just put on his hat ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Vote on Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024

Vote: No matter what your political views are, it is of the utmost importance for you to vote on Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024 and on every Election Day. If you are a woman, this right is something that was granted to you a mere 124 years ago. After I was done stitching this pattern, I decided to dedicate it to my great grandmothers (at least one is a 7x great grandmother) who were never given the opportunity to vote.  The first on the list, Mary Jane McConnell Milliken was a Revolutionary War Patriot who risked her life for the cause, giving water, blankets, and food to soldiers, yet like all women she wasn’t allowed to vote. I may have missed a few, but here are some of the women in my family that weren’t able to vote. All lived in the United States of America after the Revolutionary War: Mary Jane McConnell Milliken 1747-1815 Martha H. Pembroke Ross 1720-1781 Jane Anne James Ross 1736-1799 Hannah Johnson Taylor 1735-1776 Ruth Taylor Bailey 1758-1806 Lydia Miller Johnson 1751-1825 Elizab...
Post a Comment
Read more